I have some other responsibilities to take
care of today -- so I'll post the remainder
of the Sarah Pratt interview here:
http://www.sidneyrigdon.com/dbroadhu/OH/miscoh05.htm#122492a little later today (refresh your web-browser to view it).
But, since you mention the modern LDS rebuttal against
Sarah, I'll finish this thread with the "proof" that
modern LDS polemicists cite for her being a harlot....
Sarah continues:
>One day while my husband was asleep a paper was
>thrown into our yard, which I was curious enough to
>pick up, and found to my amazement that it was an
>"extra" containing a statement signed by Mr. and
>Mrs. Stephen H. Goddard to the effect that during
>my stay at their house I had been guilty of improper
>conduct with John C. Bennett. The falsehood stunned
>me, especially coming from such a source. Mrs.
>Goddard had always professed great friendship for
>me. During my husband's absence I had on Mrs.
>Goddard's urgent invitation passed several weeks
>with her, and while there had continued sewing for
>Mr. Bennett. I made all his shirts and Mrs. Goddard
>frequently assisted me. At one time I remember
>having done Mr. Bennett's washing. As usual Mr.
>Bennett came for his clothing, but I doubt whether
>I ever saw him alone. Mrs. Goddard was far more
>sociable with Mr. Bennett than I.
>
>On reading the statement I waked Mr. Pratt, saying:
>
>"Look at this."
>
>"Oh, take it away!" exclaimed my husband. "I can't
>read any more of their lies."
>
>"But, Mr. Pratt, surely you will go to the Goddards
>and demand an explanation?"
>
>"No, I shall not go near them. It is useless. Whatever
>they make up their minds to do they will do."
>
>"Then I'll go myself."
>
>The Goddards' house was within sight, and as I started
>to go toward it, Stephen Goddard left it and hurried away
>in an opposite direction from me. Breathless I asked
>Mrs. Goddard the meaning of the statement.
>
>"Did you sign your name yourself?" asked.
>
>"I did. I couldn't help myself. Hyrum Smith brought the
>statement and insisted upon our signing it. Both of us
>refused and told him it was not true. He commanded
>us to do as he said or it would be the worse for us. He
>declared that it was necessary to save Joseph and the
church. Mr. Goddard then concluded it was his duty to
>perjure himself, but I didn't. I told Hyrum that there was
>nothing between you and Bennett. My pleading was
>futile. The extra was to be issued and I must sign it.
>Fear alone made me lie."
Here is the published statement, from the 1842 Nauvoo Wasp:
>TESTIMONY OF MRS. GODDARD.
>
>Dr. Bennett came to my house one night about 12 o'clock,
>and sat on or beside the bed where Mrs. Pratt was and
>cursed and swore very profanely at her; she told me the
>next day that the Dr. was quick tempered and was mad
>at her, but gave no other reason. I concluded from
>circumstances that she had promised to meet him
>somewhere and had disappointed him; on another night
>I remonstrated with the Dr. and asked him what Orson
>Pratt would think, if he could know that you were so
>fond of his wife, and holding her hand so much; the Dr.
>replied that he could pull the wool over Orson's eyes.
>
>Mrs. Pratt stated to me that Dr. Bennett told her, that he
>could cause abortion with perfect safety to the mother,
>at any stage of pregnancy, and that he had frequently
>destroyed and removed infants before their time to prevent
>exposure of the parties, and that he had instruments for
>that purpose &c.
>
>My husband and I were frequently at Mrs. Pratt's and
>stayed till after 10 o'clock in the night, and Dr. Bennett
>still remained there with her and her little child alone at
>that late hour.
>
>On one occasion I came suddenly into the room where
>Mrs. Pratt and the Dr. were; she was lying on the bed
>and the Dr. was taking his hands out of her bosom; he
>was in the habit of sitting on the bed where Mrs. Pratt
>was lying, and lying down over her.
>
>I would further state that from my own observation, I am
>satisfied that their conduct was anything but virtuous,
>and I know Mrs. Pratt is not a woman of truth, and I
>believe the statements which Dr. Bennett made
>concerning Joseph Smith are false, and fabricated for
>the purpose of covering his own iniquities, and enabling
>him to practice his base designs on the innocent.
>ZERUIAH N. GODDARD.
>
>Subscribed before me one of the alderman of the City
>of Nauvoo, and sworn to this 28th day of August 1842.
>
>GEO. W. HARRIS.
>Alderman of the City of Nauvoo.
http://www.sidneyrigdon.com/dbroadhu/LDS/wasp1.htm#unknown